
Move Over, Reese’s! Indiana’s Favorite Halloween Candy for 2026 Is a Surprise
Indiana’s Favorite Halloween Candy for 2026 Might Surprise You
It is officially Halloween season! We’re so close to Halloween that if you haven’t bought your candy yet, your local Walmart might already be picked over. But if your Walmart still has some candy left and you’re wondering what the kids actually want, knowing the most popular candy in your state could help!
I was curious about what Halloween candy people in Indiana are buying the most. You might expect Reese’s, Snickers, or even M&M’s to take the top spot.
Well, according to [CandyStore.com’s 2026 Halloween candy rankings](https://www.candystore.com/apps/blog/halloween-candy-map-popular/), Indiana’s most popular Halloween candy isn’t even chocolate! I’m not a big chocolate person myself, so I can definitely get behind Indiana’s number-one pick.
Indiana’s Favorite Halloween Candy Is NERDS Gummy Clusters

That’s right! NERDS Gummy Clusters took the top spot in Indiana this year.
If you’ve never tried them, you’re missing out! They’re basically little fruity gummies covered in crunchy NERDS candy. They’re sweet, a little tart, and a pretty good choice if you’re not a huge chocolate person, especially when it comes to handing out candy to kids.
I feel like these have become so popular over the last few years, but I still wasn’t expecting them to beat out some of the Halloween classics.
And here’s what’s interesting. If you cross the river from Evansville into Kentucky or head over to Illinois, the candy rankings look completely different!
What Halloween Candy Are Our Neighboring States Buying?
According to CandyStore.com’s 2026 rankings, here’s what people in Indiana and several nearby states are buying the most:
Indiana: NERDS Gummy Clusters
Kentucky: Reese’s Cups
Illinois: Sour Patch Kids
Ohio: Blow Pops
Michigan: Starburst
I have to say, Kentucky sticking with Reese’s Cups makes sense to me. That’s one of those candies I feel like almost everyone gets excited to see in their Halloween bucket. I honestly thought Reese’s Cups would be America's number-one pick!
But Indiana choosing NERDS Gummy Clusters and Illinois going with Sour Patch Kids? Apparently, we really like our sour candy in this part of the country!
And living in Evansville, I think it’s funny that you can cross the Ohio River into Henderson and suddenly you’re in a state where Reese’s Cups take the top spot.

The Five Most Popular Halloween Candies in America
Indiana isn’t the only state showing some love for fruity candy this Halloween.
According to the rankings, these are the five most popular Halloween candies nationwide for 2026:
1. M&M’s
2. Sour Patch Kids
3. Skittles
4. Reese’s Cups
5. NERDS Gummy Clusters
I think it’s interesting that only two of the top five are chocolate candies. Growing up, I always thought getting chocolate bars was the best part of trick-or-treating, especially when someone handed out the full-size ones!
But clearly, fruity and sour candies are giving chocolate some serious competition.

Do You Agree With Indiana’s Favorite Halloween Candy?
Of course, everyone has their own opinion, and just because a candy sells the most doesn’t necessarily mean it’s everyone’s favorite.
Personally, I think one of the best parts of Halloween is going through your candy at the end of the night and seeing what you got. There was always that one candy you’d trade away and another you’d save for last.

So, I want to know what people here in Evansville and across the Tri-State think. Does Indiana have it right with NERDS Gummy Clusters, or should another candy be taking the top spot?

And if you’re handing out candy this Halloween, maybe this will help you decide what to put in that candy bowl!
You can check out the [full 2026 Halloween candy rankings from CandyStore.com] to see what the rest of the country is buying.
10 Most Popular Costumes for Halloween 2024 in Indiana
Gallery Credit: Liberty









