Evansville Has Some Seriously Spooky History You Can Actually Explore

Halloween is right around the corner, and if you're anything like me, you like feeling like you're apart of the holiday. But did you know some of Evansville's most familiar buildings have some pretty creepy stories behind them?

I'm talking about mysterious footsteps, ghost sightings, unexplained noises, and historic homes where some believe the former residents never really left.

Whether you believe in ghosts or just enjoy a little local history, there are some pretty interesting places around Evansville worth checking out.

Callie Sue
Callie Sue

Willard Library and the Mysterious Grey Lady

Let's start with probably the most famous ghost story in Evansville: the Grey Lady of Willard Library.

The library opened in 1885, and honestly, the building already looks like something straight out of a scary movie.

According to the library, the legend started in 1937 when a custodian reportedly spotted a mysterious woman wearing a grey dress and veil in the basement. Before he could figure out who she was, she disappeared.

And apparently, she wasn't done making appearances.

Over the years, visitors and employees have reported strange footsteps, books falling from shelves, furniture moving, and even mysterious perfume smells.

Some believe the Grey Lady could be Louise Carpenter, the daughter of the library's founder, although nobody knows for sure.

Here's the fun part. Willard Library actually has ghost cameras you can watch online to see if you spot anything yourself!

Callie Sue
Callie Sue

The Reitz Home Museum and Its Victorian Past

If old Victorian mansions give you the creeps, you might want to check out the Reitz Home Museum in downtown Evansville.

Built in 1871 for businessman John Augustus Reitz, the mansion is now a museum where visitors can step back in time and see how one of Evansville's prominent families lived.

But the home's history isn't all glamorous.

The Reitz family experienced tragedy, including the death of Edward Reitz in a boating accident in 1892. His story has been included in local haunted history tours.

The mansion has also been featured on Haunted Historic Evansville walking tours, where actors bring stories of the city's past to life.

And even if you don't believe in ghosts, touring a mansion that's more than 150 years old is pretty interesting on its own.

Explore the Reitz Home Museum

Callie Sue
Callie Sue

The Riverside Historic District Has Ghost Stories of Its Own

One thing I love about downtown Evansville is how much history you can find just by walking around.

The Riverside Historic District is filled with beautiful old homes, but some of them have stories that are a little less charming.

Take the Manor House on Southeast Second Street, for example.

According to Evansville Living, the home was built in 1868 for Henry Gwathmey and his wife, Mary Eliza, who sadly died shortly after the house was completed.

Over the years, residents have reportedly spotted a mysterious woman dressed in black near the staircase and windows. Some believe it could be Mary Eliza herself.

Of course, there's no proof that the house is haunted, but it certainly makes you wonder!

The neighborhood has also been featured in Haunted Historic Evansville walking tours. While this year's October tours have already passed, you can still take a walk through the historic district and admire the architecture from public sidewalks.

Learn More About Haunted Historic Evansville

Callie Sue
Callie Sue

The Carpenter House Has Some Unexplained Stories Too

Another historic building with a spooky reputation is the Carpenter House, once home to Willard Carpenter, the founder of Willard Library.

Built in 1849, the home later served as the former headquarters of WNIN.

According to Evansville Living, employees reported some unusual experiences, including sightings of women dressed in clothing from the 1800s.

In 2010, paranormal investigators spent three days exploring the property and claimed to hear mysterious footsteps, groaning noises, and other unexplained sounds.

Now, whether that was something paranormal or just an old house making noise, I'll let you decide.

The building isn't a public ghost attraction, but you can still appreciate its historic exterior from public areas.

A Little Local History With a Spooky Twist

Personally, I think that's what makes these stories so interesting. You don't have to believe in ghosts to appreciate the history behind them.

These are buildings we drive past all the time, and some have been standing for more than a century.

So, if you're looking for something a little different to do before Halloween, check out Willard Library's ghost cameras, visit the Reitz Home, or take a walk through downtown Evansville's historic district.

And the next time you're browsing the bookshelves at Willard Library, maybe keep an eye out for the Grey Lady. You never know who might be browsing with you!

9 Evansville Businesses You May Not Recognize Now

Evansville, Indiana, is full of business news every week. There are stores and restaurants opening and closing quite often. It's hard to keep up with each side of the city.

Gallery Credit: Liberty

Sources

Willard Library: Ghost Cams

Reitz Home Museum

Evansville Living: Haunted History

 

 

More From My WJLT 105.3