When I lived in Princeton, the only way to enjoy the unique taste of Sandy's Pizza was to drive the 15 or so miles to Ft. Branch. You could also order ahead and have a delivery driver meet you halfway in a parking lot. In 2015, a second Sandy's Pizza location opened in Princeton, but soon Gibson County will be back down to only 1 Sandy's Pizza.

48 Years in the Pizza Business

My grandparents used to rave about the peppers that you could get at Sandy's Pizza. Something about the way they marinated them, and I loved the crust. The original Ft. Branch location is basically a building full of history.

The Coke Room Seats 70 - The Elvis Room is Pretty Special


See More in This Youtube Video

Sandy's Pizza Closing

Due to ongoing difficulties in staffing, Sandy’s Pizza in Princeton Indiana will be consolidated into our Fort Branch restaurant and the Princeton location will be closed on August 15, 2022. Some restaurant equipment will be available for sale and the building is available for lease. Sandy’s Pizza in Fort Branch will function the same as it has for the past 48 years. We sincerely thank the people in the Princeton area for supporting our restaurant there and look forward to continuing to serve you through our Fort Branch location.
Contact Dan Bittner about equipment purchases at 812-453-7254

2007 Domino's / 2018 Sandy's Pizza

GOOGLE MAPS 2007 2018
2007 2018
My WJLT 105.3 logo
Get our free mobile app

Princeton Location will close August 15, 2022


15 Best Pizza Restaurants in Southern Indiana

When you're looking to get your pizza fix, these are the best places in the Evansville area to go according to residents.

Then and Now: See How Princeton, Indiana has Changed Over the Years

I grew up in Princeton, IN and everytime I go back to visit, it seems like more and more has changed. It's not my imagination. Google Maps has a back in time feature, and it took me from 2007 to 2012, and some of the photos are from 2018.

10 Things Only People From Princeton, Indiana Will Understand

Things seem to be changing so fast in Princeton, Indiana. There is a lot of history that only the locals can really appreciate.

More From My WJLT 105.3