University of Evansville Announces 2026 Outstanding Educator Winners

It’s always a great day when we get to celebrate the people shaping the future of our community – and that’s exactly what just happened right here in Evansville! The University of Evansville rolled out the red carpet (and a few fun surprises!) to honor four incredible local educators during its 35th annual Outstanding Educator Awards.

These awards shine a spotlight on teachers and principals across Vanderburgh County who go above and beyond every single day – and this year’s winners truly deliver.

Outstanding Elementary Teacher of the Year

The Outstanding Elementary Teacher of the Year is Holly Carey from McCutchanville Elementary. Holly has spent more than two decades in the classroom, building confidence, kindness, and leadership in her students. Whether it’s through hands-on learning or leading student initiatives that promote positivity, she’s creating a classroom where kids feel seen, supported, and excited to learn.

Outstanding Middle School Teacher of the Year

The Outstanding Middle School Teacher of the Year is Stefanie Simmons from Corpus Christi School. She’s the kind of teacher who connects with students at every level, teaching science while also mentoring and guiding kids across multiple grades. From organizing big milestone moments like graduation to leading student groups, she’s deeply woven into the fabric of her school community.

ALSO READ: Vote Now to Help Evansville Educator Win America’s Favorite Teacher!

Outstanding High School Teacher of the Year

The Outstanding High School Teacher of the Year is Maren Smith from North High School. She’s preparing students for the real world through a college-level anatomy course, giving them a head start on careers in healthcare and science. Her hands-on approach and real-life applications make learning come alive – and her students clearly benefit from that energy and dedication.

Get our free mobile app

Outstanding Principal of the Year

And finally, the Outstanding Principal of the Year is Dr. Andrew Freeman at Central High School. Under his leadership, Central has earned national recognition year after year. But what really stands out is his people-first approach – making sure students and staff feel heard, valued, and supported every step of the way. Take a look at the Central student surprising Dr. Freeman with the amazing award!

These educators are making a real difference in the lives of local students – and it’s something Evansville can be incredibly proud of.