Top 10 Best Pizza Places in Henderson, KY (Yelp-Ranked)

Top 10 Pizza Places in Henderson, Kentucky According to Yelp

Yesterday I was craving pizza and I didn't feel like cooking so I went to order a pizza and ran into a problem. I don't live in the tiny town of Red Bud anymore where your only option for pizza is a Pizza Hut or Casey's Pizza. So, when I typed in pizza near me a whole list of places popped up and I got to thinking what is everyone's top ten pizza places around here? My friend Travis wrote an article about the 'Top Ten Favorite Pizza Spots in Evansville'. Well, what about the folks over there in Kentucky?

If you're craving pizza in Henderson, these are the spots earning some of the best Yelp ratings and reviews. From local institutions serving cracker-thin crust to wood-fired favorites and riverfront pizza joints, here's a look at the Top 10 pizza places in Henderson based on Yelp ratings, review volume, and customer feedback.

Let me tell you, these pies look pretty dang good. Not only do I have ten pizza joints to try in Evansville but now I have ten more to try in Henderson! I better get comfortable ordering take out!

10. Pony Express Pizza

Pony Express Pizza

Address: 343 3rd St, Henderson, KY 42420, United States
Phone: +1 270-826-2770

A downtown Henderson classic known for its breadsticks, specialty pizzas, and buy-one-get-one deals that keep customers coming back.

9. JJ'S CAFE

JJ'S CAFE

Address: 506 N Green St, Henderson, KY 42420, United States
Phone: +1 270-212-0941

Also known as JJ's Burgers & Pies, this local favorite serves deep-dish and specialty pizzas alongside burgers and wings.

8. Mister B's Pizza & Wings

Mister B's Pizza & Wings

Address: 2611 US-41, Henderson, KY 42420, United States
Phone: +1 270-826-9999

A popular spot for pizza, wings, and game-day gatherings. It's one of the most reviewed pizza restaurants in Henderson.

7. Firedome Wood Fired Pizza

Firedome Wood Fired Pizza

Address: 512 Barret Blvd, Henderson, KY 42420, United States
Phone: +1 270-831-1977

Known for its wood-fired pizzas, wings, and sports-bar vibe. Fans praise the crispy crust and specialty pizzas.

6. Kelsey G's Pizza & More

Kelsey G's Pizza & More

Address: 508 Watson Ln, Henderson, KY 42420, United States
Phone: +1 270-830-0039

A family-owned neighborhood pizza spot that's earned loyal fans for its thin-crust pizzas and laid-back atmosphere.

5. Mama's Pizza

Mama's Pizza

Address: 1526 N Green St, Henderson, KY 42420, United States
Phone: +1 270-830-0101

A longtime Henderson staple serving large specialty pizzas with a slightly sweet sauce and family-friendly atmosphere.

4. Rockhouse On The River

Rockhouse On The River

Address: 212 N Water St, Henderson, KY 42420, United States
Phone: +1 270-212-1400

Great pizza paired with one of the best views in town. Located on the riverfront, it's especially known for its strombolis and house-made dough pizzas.

3. Crust and Roll Pizza&Sushi

Crust and Roll Pizza&Sushi

Address: 2278 S Green St, Henderson, KY 42420, United States
Phone: +1 270-212-0000

One of Henderson's newer concepts, combining wood-fired pizza and sushi under one roof. Customers rave about the crust and creative specialty pizzas.

2. Rick's Una Pizza

Rick's Una Pizza

Address: 338 S Green St, Henderson, KY 42420, United States
Phone: +1 270-826-2242

A local institution famous for both its classic Una-style thin crust and Chicago-style stuffed pizzas. The strombolis are also a major draw.

1. Dave's Pizza

Dave's Pizza

Address: 614 N Green St, Henderson, KY 42420, United States
Phone: +1 270-826-8111

A Henderson favorite known for its thin, cracker-style crust and square-cut pizzas. Many reviewers call it the best pizza in town and praise the consistency and generous toppings.

Honorable Mentions

Casey's
Little Caesars Pizza
Pizza Hut
Papa Johns Pizza

Sources

Yelp ratings and reviews, local business listings, and customer review data.

Local debate starter: If you ask Henderson locals, you'll probably hear Dave's, Rick's Una Pizza, and Rockhouse mentioned the most when the conversation turns to "best pizza in town."